SYNTHETIC REVIEW EXAMPLE
Sales increased; the cause is unconfirmed
Invented Lantern Workshop reports September sales of AUD 84,000 and profit of AUD 18,400. The supplied files support the copied figures and comparison with August. They do not establish why sales rose or whether cash reconciles.
- September sales
- AUD 84,000
invented-ledger.csv, logical record 2, column 2 - September wages
- AUD 31,000
invented-ledger.csv, logical record 3, column 2 - September profit
- AUD 18,400
invented-ledger.csv, logical record 4, column 2
What the supplied figures support
Sales rose by AUD 5,000 from August to September: 84,000 minus 79,000. Wages rose by AUD 500 and profit rose by AUD 2,300. These calculations compare the supplied periods and do not reconcile a ledger.
What the reviewer corrected
The hypothetical draft attributed higher sales to an exhibition. The notes record that an exhibition occurred but contain no attribution evidence. The reviewed wording leaves the cause unconfirmed.
What is missing and what to ask
No bank statement or cash reconciliation was supplied. Profit is not cash. Ask for a sales breakdown and evidence of the exhibition effect before drawing a causal conclusion. These are manual review questions, not financial advice.